Beyond Usability: Financial-Report Understandability in Digital Accounting for Indonesian Village-Owned Enterprises
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.33795/ws9ahx67Keywords:
accounting information systems, financial-report understandability, mixed methods, system usability, village-owned enterprisesAbstract
Digital accounting can make transaction recording easier, but an easier system does not necessarily make its financial reports easier to understand. This study examines the difference between system usability and financial-report understandability in two Indonesian village-owned enterprises by comparing two versions of a digital accounting application. An explanatory mixed-methods approach was used. Thirty-five evaluators completed task-based usability assessments for both application versions, while 27 complete questionnaires provided additional evidence on technology acceptance. Qualitative evidence was obtained from interviews with four managers, six field visits, facilitator observations, and document reviews. The results show that the weighted mean usability score increased from 69.06 to 72.38 after manual account-code selection was replaced with administrator-defined mappings that connected familiar transaction descriptions to accounting entries. The improvement was most evident among operational users, while trained facilitators showed little change. Despite generally positive responses to the system, managers still needed assistance to identify profit or loss, understand financial position, and explain financial trends. These findings show that being able to operate an accounting system and being able to understand its financial outputs are related, but they are not the same outcome. Digital accounting systems designed for non-accountant users should therefore be evaluated not only for ease of use, but also for how well users can interpret and communicate the financial information they produce.